This was a beautifully filmed, but mostly incomprehensible adaptation of James Ellroy's own speculative fiction about the real-life murder of aspiring movie starlet Elizabeth Short. The roles are actually prretty easy to sum up. Scarlet Johansson pouts and looks pretty, Aarron Eckhart broods, Josh Hartnett bumbles around with wrinkled forebrow, and Mia Kirchner hilariously overacts in the role of a struggling bad actor. Meanwhile, Hilary Swank steals the show with her luxurious 40's coiffure and smouldering gaze.
The movie is not without its redeeming factors, however. In addition to the gorgeous cinematography and the creepily alluring Swank, the seediness of 40's Los Angeles practically drips from the screen. In the end, however, Black Dahlia can't overcome its mish-mash of unrrelated storylines and contrived climactic scene.